CleanerSolutions Database
Toxics Use Reduction Institute · Surface Solutions Laboratory
 
Toxics Use Reduction Institute




Surface Solutions Laboratory

Trial Report



Trial Number 434

(Client Number 153, Project Number 1)

Trial Purpose: Laboratory evaluations of alternative cleaning products

Date Run: 11/27/07

Experiment Procedure:
Several "do-it-yourself" home formulations were evaluated for performance on several substrates and typical soils for bathroom cleaning.

Cleaning: Spray cleaner on the coupons
10 secs Manual Wipe cleaning at 130 F

Contaminant SSL Soil 1 - Bathroom Soil
Substrate 2"x 4"x 0.06
Chrome Plated Coupons
Ceramic Coupons
Fiberglass Coupons(3"x 4.5"x 0.125")

Bathroom Cleaners -Tub & Tile Cleaners

Home Formulation 22 - Baking soda, sprinkle it on the tub/tile and scrub with a damp sponge.

Home Formulation 23 - Vinegar and baking soda will remove film buildup on the tub. Apply vinegar on a sponge and wipe tiles. Use baking soda as you would scouring powder. Rinse thoroughly.

Home Formulation 24 - ? cup vinegar in gallon water to use on surfaces that have films or need more cleaning.

Home Formulation 25 - Baking soda and water paste to clean grout. Put paste on grout with toothpaste or sponge, scrub grout and then rinse and throw rest of paste away

Home Formulation 26 - Rub area to be cleaned with half a lemon dipped in borax. Rinse well and dry with soft cloth

Home Formulation 27 - Baking soda and Murphy?s oil. Use baking soda in place of scouring powder. Sprinkle baking soda on wet tub and rub. Then add some soap and continue scrubbing. Rinse well.

Trial Results
Product          Substrate         Average (%)
Formulation 22   Chrome Plated      -135.31
                 Ceramic            -114.70
                 Fiberglass         -196.55

Formulation 23   Chrome Plated      -168.64
                 Ceramic            -172.14
                 Fiberglass          -46.52

Formulation 24   Chrome Plated        82.24
                 Ceramic              46.93
                 Fiberglass           99.44

Formulation 25   Chrome Plated        10.27
                 Ceramic            -346.15
                 Fiberglass         -250.63  

Formulation 26   Chrome Plated       -20.44
                 Ceramic            -261.92
                 Fiberglass         -246.50

Formulation 27   Chrome Plated      -110.20
                 Ceramic            -208.47
                 Fiberglass         -166.09


Success Rating
Lab evaluation based on vendor data.

Conclusion
Many of the mixtures left behind a lot of residue when using the standard laboratory procedures for commercial cleaning products. Modification of the cleaning process may improve the effectiveness of these "do-it-yourself" formulations.

Formulation 24 was the only product to remove over 75% of the bathroom soil using manual wiping.