CleanerSolutions Database
Toxics Use Reduction Institute · Surface Solutions Laboratory
Toxics Use Reduction Institute

Surface Solutions Laboratory

Trial Report

Trial Number 8

(Client Number 155, Project Number 1)

Trial Purpose: Evaluating cleaners for removal.

Date Run: 09/20/01

Experiment Procedure:
Ten cleaners were selected based on previous trials and lab databases. Solutions that were diluted to 5% using DI water in 250 ml beakers. All solutions were heated to 120 F on a hot plate.
Twenty-one preweighed coupons were coated with the supplied slurry using a plastic eye dropper and allowed to dry for 2 hours. These coupons were then weighed again. Three coupons were immersed into each beaker to be cleaned for 15 minutes. After the cleaning, the coupons were rinsed in DI water and dried using air blow off. Coupons were then weighed a final time and percent efficiencies were calculated for each cleaner.

Nalco Chemical Co Nalco 2350 Polishing Slurry

Trial Results
The increase in cleaning increased the efficiencies of all of the products.  Efficiencies ranged from 99.36 to 99.88%. The following table lists the
calculated efficiencies for each product tested.  Safety First had the highest efficiency even with a decrease in the products concentration.  In the
previous trial, Safety First was at 15% by volume and in this trial, the product was further diluted to 5%.

Table 1.  Cleaning Efficiencies                            
Cleaner       Coupon1 Coupon2  Coupon3  Average   Std Dev  Rank
Amberclean   99.53       99.77       99.87       99.72       0.18       2
Micro 90       99.86       99.34       98.95       99.38       0.46       6
LPS              99.58       99.31       99.60       99.50       0.16       4
ND 17           99.84       99.57       99.46       99.62       0.19       3
Inproclean     99.53       99.28       99.26       99.36       0.15       7
Polyspray      99.26       99.27       99.72       99.42       0.26       5
Safety First    99.91       99.86       99.88       99.88       0.03       1

Success Rating
A follow up test, usually based on company input.

These seven cleaners will be evaluated on the second supplied polishing compound, Saint-Gobain Inustrial Ceramics Water Based Alumina. Operating conditions will remain the same.