Default object view. Click to create a custom template, Node ID: 7646, Object ID: 7645

Trial #0

Trial #0

To evaluate the efficacy of supplied dishwashing cleaners in removing standard food soil from ceramic, glass, and stainless steel coupons.

2017

24

5

0

0

Coupon

05/25/2017

30.00

Low Pressure Spray

Vinh Tran

Ceramics
Glass/Quartz
Stainless Steel

Food

Tap water spray

Air Blowoff
Air dry

Gravimetric
Visual

Soiling Process:

A total of 15 trials were conducted, with five trials per dishwashing cleaner. For each trial a set of nine ceramic, a set of nine glass, and a set of nine stainless steel coupons were weighed on an analytical balance to determine their initial weights. The coupons were then soiled with 0.5 grams of standard food soil which consists of 80% margarine and 20% powdered milk using a hand held swab. The coupons were weighed again to obtain the amount of contaminant added. Following this a set of six dinner plates were soiled with 6.66 grams of standard food soil.

Cleaning Process:

The coupons were then placed on the top rack of the dishwasher, along with six tall glass tumblers and four small glass tumblers. The bottom rack of the dishwasher was loaded with four small dinner plates and six cereal bowls. In addition, a basket of assorted stainless steel cutlery was placed in the middle of the bottom rack. For each set of cleaning, the respective cleaner was poured until the detergent slot was filled. The dishwasher was then ran for 50-minutes as one trial cycle. After the cycle was finished, the six tall glass tumblers and four small glass tumblers were evaluated visually by a panel of three in regards to spotting and filming. The coupons were removed from the dishwasher and allowed to dry for 1 hour before being re-weighing to obtain the amount of contaminated removed.

The following rating scale from 1-5 was used for visual ratings on the glass tumblers:

Spotting Filming
1 No spots None
2 Random spots Barely
3 ¼ covered Slight
4 ½ covered Moderate
5 completely covered Heavy

Gravimetric Analysis:
In regards to the ceramic substrates the Seventh Generation cleaner was most effective out of the cleaners, with an overall average removal of 96.27% as opposed to 94.79% for the AGAE cleaner and 92.66% for the Cascade cleaner. For glass, the most effective cleaner was the Cascade cleaner with an overall removal of 99.6%, barely edging out the Seventh Generation cleaner, which had an overall percentage removal of 99.59% and the AGAE cleaner with 99.49%. For stainless steel, the most effective cleaner was the Seventh Generation cleaner with an overall average percentage removal of 98.75%, eclipsing the AGAE and Cascade cleaners, which had overall average percentage removals of 96.23% and 96.48% respectively.

Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel_Ceramic_Trial 1 0.4885 0.0171 96.50 96.81 94.79
0.4905 0.0179 96.35    
0.4953 0.0147 97.03    
0.4874 0.0164 96.64    
0.4898 0.0127 97.41    
0.4822 0.0116 97.59    
0.4849 0.0162 96.66    
0.4925 0.0188 96.18    
0.4888 0.0152 96.89    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Ceramic_Trial 2 0.5067 0.0482 90.49 94.10  
0.4929 0.0210 95.74    
0.4928 0.0210 95.74    
0.4912 0.0159 96.76    
0.5085 0.0331 93.49    
0.4995 0.0202 95.96    
0.5077 0.0204 95.98    
0.4980 0.0201 95.96    
0.4911 0.0649 86.78    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Ceramic_Trial 3 0.5004 0.0348 93.05 93.18  
0.4912 0.0351 92.85    
0.5123 0.0359 92.99    
0.5024 0.0261 94.80    
0.4932 0.0399 91.91    
0.5129 0.0264 94.85    
0.4878 0.0652 86.63    
0.4928 0.0178 96.39    
0.5001 0.0243 95.14    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Ceramic_Trial 4 0.4988 0.0295 94.09 94.92  
0.5189 0.0180 96.53    
0.5124 0.0518 89.89    
0.5009 0.0189 96.23    
0.5007 0.0231 95.39    
0.5004 0.0163 96.74    
0.4989 0.0233 95.33    
0.4938 0.0330 93.32    
0.5027 0.0163 96.76    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Ceramic_Trial 5 0.4891 0.0198 95.95 94.95  
0.4938 0.0419 91.51    
0.5066 0.0199 96.07    
0.4944 0.0210 95.75    
0.5054 0.0273 94.60    
0.4881 0.0183 96.25    
0.5071 0.0258 94.91    
0.4933 0.0342 93.07    
0.4945 0.0176 96.44    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Glass_Trial 1 0.4894 0.0014 99.71 99.59 99.49
0.4919 0.0026 99.47    
0.4888 0.0029 99.41    
0.4895 0.0014 99.71    
0.4842 0.0011 99.77    
0.4899 0.0007 99.86    
0.5034 0.0028 99.44    
0.5021 0.0018 99.64    
0.4982 0.0036 99.28    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Glass_Trial 2 0.4824 0.0021 99.56 99.44  
0.5145 0.0022 99.57    
0.4996 0.0030 99.40    
0.4890 0.0040 99.18    
0.4868 0.0022 99.55    
0.5214 0.0048 99.08    
0.4916 0.0019 99.61    
0.5042 0.0028 99.44    
0.5036 0.0021 99.58    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Glass_Trial 3 0.5076 0.0016 99.68 99.57  
0.5311 0.0033 99.38    
0.3856 0.0027 99.30    
0.5040 0.0017 99.66    
0.5076 0.0034 99.33    
0.4858 0.0006 99.88    
0.5005 0.0010 99.80    
0.4997 0.0023 99.54    
0.5399 0.0026 99.52    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Glass_Trial 4 0.5025 0.0002 99.96 99.71  
0.4949 0.0002 99.96    
0.5028 0.0030 99.40    
0.4868 0.0003 99.94    
0.4811 0.0016 99.67    
0.4975 0.0028 99.44    
0.4962 0.0019 99.62    
0.4853 0.0026 99.46    
0.5000 0.0004 99.92    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Glass_Trial 5 0.4886 0.0002 99.96 99.17  
0.4915 0.0055 98.88    
0.4908 0.0039 99.21    
0.4879 0.0032 99.34    
0.4945 0.0057 98.85    
0.4986 0.0031 99.38    
0.5030 0.0072 98.57    
0.4912 0.0042 99.15    
0.5018 0.0041 99.18    
         
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 1 0.4981 0.0067 98.65 98.02 96.23
0.4801 0.0091 98.10    
0.4841 0.0065 98.66    
0.4800 0.0089 98.15    
0.4866 0.0110 97.74    
0.4883 0.0098 97.99    
0.4831 0.0098 97.97    
0.4899 0.0110 97.75    
0.4858 0.0139 97.14    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 2 0.4860 0.0081 98.33 94.89  
0.5037 0.0122 97.58    
0.4973 0.0071 98.57    
0.5021 0.0098 98.05    
0.5012 0.0114 97.73    
0.4959 0.0514 89.64    
0.5002 0.0069 98.62    
0.4924 0.0128 97.40    
0.4864 0.1064 78.13    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 3 0.4966 0.0212 95.73 95.55  
0.4864 0.0098 97.99    
0.5007 0.0226 95.49    
0.5219 0.0348 93.33    
0.4960 0.0340 93.15    
0.5315 0.0262 95.07    
0.5048 0.0227 95.50    
0.5116 0.0111 97.83    
0.5137 0.0212 95.87    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 4 0.4931 0.0275 94.42 95.92  
0.4969 0.0215 95.67    
0.5177 0.0203 96.08    
0.4957 0.0161 96.75    
0.5122 0.0117 97.72    
0.5017 0.0304 93.94    
0.5090 0.0213 95.82    
0.5216 0.0177 96.61    
0.5006 0.0186 96.28    
AGAE Dishwasher Detergent Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 5 0.5066 0.0130 97.43 96.78  
2.4983 0.0237 99.05    
0.5034 0.0235 95.33    
0.4966 0.0173 96.52    
0.5026 0.0269 94.65    
0.4874 0.0334 93.15    
0.5036 0.0067 98.67    
0.4882 0.0096 98.03    
0.5060 0.0093 98.16    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Ceramic_Trial 1 0.4800 0.0142 97.04 96.27 96.27
0.4816 0.0397 91.76    
0.4891 0.0172 96.48    
0.5033 0.0130 97.42    
0.4802 0.0179 96.27    
0.4887 0.0140 97.14    
0.4909 0.0176 96.41    
0.4815 0.0102 97.88    
0.4813 0.0190 96.05    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Ceramic_Trial 2 0.4873 0.0222 95.44 95.98  
0.4889 0.0201 95.89    
0.4952 0.0164 96.69    
0.4958 0.0142 97.14    
0.4910 0.0170 96.54    
0.4935 0.0170 96.56    
0.4866 0.0212 95.64    
0.4876 0.0148 96.96    
0.4840 0.0340 92.98    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Ceramic_Trial 3 0.5063 0.0299 94.09 95.45  
0.4932 0.0428 91.32    
0.5060 0.0193 96.19    
0.4939 0.0143 97.10    
0.5003 0.0167 96.66    
0.4968 0.0179 96.40    
0.5007 0.0192 96.17    
0.5027 0.0153 96.96    
0.4999 0.0292 94.16    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Ceramic_Trial 4 0.4881 0.0153 96.87 97.22  
0.4919 0.0143 97.09    
0.4975 0.0131 97.37    
0.4980 0.0174 96.51    
0.4937 0.0134 97.29    
0.4931 0.0116 97.65    
0.4914 0.0146 97.03    
0.4898 0.0103 97.90    
0.4959 0.0134 97.30    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Ceramic_Trial 5 0.4930 0.0177 96.41 96.44  
0.4799 0.0168 96.50    
0.4806 0.0140 97.09    
0.4869 0.0186 96.18    
0.4858 0.0182 96.25    
0.4982 0.0249 95.00    
0.4938 0.0166 96.64    
0.4860 0.0142 97.08    
0.4838 0.0153 96.84    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Glass_Trial 1 0.4910 0.0036 99.27 99.57 99.59
0.5018 0.0046 99.08    
0.4853 0.0012 99.75    
0.4874 0.0015 99.69    
0.5566 0.0037 99.34    
0.4960 0.0021 99.58    
0.4899 0.0023 99.53    
0.4862 0.0003 99.94    
0.5000 0.0004 99.92    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Glass_Trial 2 0.4910 0.0036 99.27 99.56  
0.5018 0.0046 99.08    
0.4853 0.0012 99.75    
0.4874 0.0015 99.69    
0.4966 0.0037 99.25    
0.4960 0.0021 99.58    
0.4899 0.0023 99.53    
0.4862 0.0003 99.94    
0.5000 0.0004 99.92    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Glass_Trial 3 0.5036 0.0034 99.32 99.55  
0.4965 0.0017 99.66    
0.4960 0.0027 99.46    
0.4854 0.0026 99.46    
0.4969 0.0021 99.58    
0.5036 0.0018 99.64    
0.4907 0.0019 99.61    
0.4963 0.0021 99.58    
0.5011 0.0016 99.68    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Glass_Trial 4 0.5007 0.0011 99.78 99.73  
0.4960 0.0009 99.82    
0.4883 0.0018 99.63    
0.4989 0.0012 99.76    
0.4983 0.0009 99.82    
0.4905 0.0012 99.76    
0.4948 0.0016 99.68    
0.4940 0.0011 99.78    
0.4959 0.0023 99.54    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Glass_Trial 5 0.4986 0.0022 99.56 99.57  
0.4875 0.0018 99.63    
0.4903 0.0026 99.47    
0.4990 0.0015 99.70    
0.4949 0.0026 99.47    
0.4938 0.0018 99.64    
0.4977 0.0026 99.48    
0.4948 0.0011 99.78    
0.5178 0.0033 99.36    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 1 0.4879 0.0056 98.85 98.77 98.75
0.4990 0.0112 97.76    
0.4861 0.0053 98.91    
0.4871 0.0064 98.69    
0.4961 0.0049 99.01    
0.4953 0.0030 99.39    
0.4885 0.0079 98.38    
0.4988 0.0052 98.96    
0.4958 0.0050 98.99    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 2 0.4922 0.0066 98.66 98.51  
0.4720 0.0066 98.60    
0.4816 0.0053 98.90    
0.5010 0.0074 98.52    
0.4734 0.0057 98.80    
0.4934 0.0113 97.71    
0.4996 0.0033 99.34    
0.4798 0.0140 97.08    
0.4921 0.0052 98.94    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 3 0.4981 0.0065 98.70 99.00  
0.4988 0.0036 99.28    
0.4980 0.0067 98.65    
0.4961 0.0009 99.82    
0.4946 0.0021 99.58    
0.5045 0.0052 98.97    
0.4884 0.0033 99.32    
0.4835 0.0099 97.95    
0.5022 0.0065 98.71    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 4 0.4913 0.0038 99.23 99.30  
0.4966 0.0014 99.72    
0.4978 0.0059 98.81    
0.4998 0.0004 99.92    
0.4967 0.0045 99.09    
0.4886 0.0035 99.28    
0.4906 0.0042 99.14    
0.4941 0.0040 99.19    
0.4972 0.0033 99.34    
Seventh Generation Dishwasher Gel _Stainless Steel_Trial 5 0.5046 0.0060 98.81 98.19  
0.4976 0.0036 99.28    
0.4844 0.0030 99.38    
0.4932 0.0060 98.78    
0.4986 0.0179 96.41    
0.4861 0.0107 97.80    
0.5004 0.0058 98.84    
0.5044 0.0201 96.02    
0.4944 0.0081 98.36    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
Cascade_Ceramic_Trial 1 0.4856 0.0180 96.29 96.23 92.66
0.4939 0.0217 95.61    
0.4935 0.0133 97.31    
0.4925 0.0136 97.24    
0.4889 0.0192 96.07    
0.4896 0.0150 96.94    
0.4905 0.0130 97.35    
0.4827 0.0212 95.61    
0.4936 0.0312 93.68    
Cascade_Ceramic_Trial 2 0.4931 0.0237 95.19 88.53  
0.4881 0.0217 95.55    
0.4996 0.0270 94.60    
0.4890 0.3192 34.72    
0.4916 0.0275 94.41    
0.4989 0.0198 96.03    
0.5012 0.0202 95.97    
0.4942 0.0247 95.00    
0.4970 0.0232 95.33    
Cascade_Ceramic_Trial 3 0.4945 0.0170 96.56 95.50  
0.5002 0.0251 94.98    
0.4880 0.0178 96.35    
0.4870 0.0249 94.89    
0.4998 0.0163 96.74    
0.4869 0.0216 95.56    
0.4996 0.0335 93.29    
0.4922 0.0203 95.88    
0.4965 0.0238 95.21    
Cascade_Ceramic_Trial 4 0.4967 0.0428 91.38 94.38  
0.4969 0.0226 95.45    
0.4977 0.0287 94.23    
0.4910 0.0259 94.73    
0.4952 0.0211 95.74    
0.4966 0.0297 94.02    
0.4941 0.0423 91.44    
0.4986 0.0190 96.19    
0.4958 0.0188 96.21    
Cascade_Ceramic_Trial 5 0.4910 0.0233 95.25 88.66  
0.4904 0.0229 95.33    
0.4881 0.1721 64.74    
0.4825 0.0186 96.15    
0.5021 0.0212 95.78    
0.4865 0.0287 94.10    
0.4927 0.0156 96.83    
0.4921 0.1819 63.04    
0.5024 0.0166 96.70    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
Cascade_Glass_Trial 1 0.4991 0.0020 99.60 99.53 99.60
0.4967 0.0007 99.86    
0.4922 0.0017 99.65    
0.4930 0.0019 99.61    
0.4930 0.0016 99.68    
0.4915 0.0015 99.69    
0.4886 0.0012 99.75    
0.5027 0.0049 99.03    
0.5040 0.0058 98.85    
Cascade_Glass_Trial 2 0.4994 0.0006 99.88 99.66  
0.4969 0.0052 98.95    
0.4966 0.0013 99.74    
0.4973 0.0010 99.80    
0.5036 0.0006 99.88    
0.5073 0.0011 99.78    
0.4957 0.0016 99.68    
0.4994 0.0015 99.70    
0.4950 0.0023 99.54    
Cascade_Glass_Trial 3 0.4946 0.0011 99.78 99.63  
0.4966 0.0014 99.72    
0.5025 0.0025 99.50    
0.4968 0.0017 99.66    
0.4955 0.0020 99.60    
0.4974 0.0021 99.58    
0.4961 0.0016 99.68    
0.4965 0.0018 99.64    
0.5043 0.0024 99.52    
Cascade_Glass_Trial 4 0.4998 0.0026 99.48 99.58  
0.4884 0.0005 99.90    
0.4970 0.0024 99.52    
0.4927 0.0011 99.78    
0.4898 0.0018 99.63    
0.5015 0.0021 99.58    
0.4974 0.0024 99.52    
0.5056 0.0017 99.66    
0.4987 0.0041 99.18    
Cascade_Glass_Trial 5 0.5384 0.0041 99.24 99.61  
0.4990 0.0022 99.56    
0.4882 0.0018 99.63    
0.4965 0.0009 99.82    
0.5032 0.0014 99.72    
0.4946 0.0027 99.45    
0.4970 0.0023 99.54    
0.4961 0.0012 99.76    
0.4966 0.0011 99.78    
Cleaner Initial wt Final wt %Removed Trial Avg % Overall %Removed
Cascade_Stainless Steel_Trial 1 0.4972 0.0846 82.98 91.55 96.48
0.4893 0.0644 86.84    
0.4953 0.0209 95.78    
0.4856 0.0322 93.37    
0.4936 0.0332 93.27    
0.4937 0.0243 95.08    
0.4964 0.0472 90.49    
0.4836 0.0437 90.96    
0.4944 0.0240 95.15    
Cascade_Stainless Steel_Trial 2 0.4992 0.0029 99.42 99.44  
0.4881 0.0008 99.84    
0.4896 0.0013 99.73    
0.4898 0.0031 99.37    
0.4903 0.0033 99.33    
0.4965 0.0036 99.27    
0.9096 0.0036 99.60    
0.4976 0.0044 99.12    
0.5065 0.0035 99.31    
Cascade_Stainless Steel_Trial 3 0.4964 0.0121 97.56 98.56  
0.4882 0.0092 98.12    
0.4933 0.0052 98.95    
0.4996 0.0094 98.12    
0.4917 0.0090 98.17    
0.4986 0.0043 99.14    
0.4896 0.0031 99.37    
0.5051 0.0060 98.81    
0.4989 0.0058 98.84    
Cascade_Stainless Steel_Trial 4 0.5053 0.0047 99.07 98.56  
0.5066 0.0112 97.79    
0.4882 0.0083 98.30    
0.4927 0.0077 98.44    
0.4906 0.0109 97.78    
0.4976 0.0054 98.91    
0.4987 0.0064 98.72    
0.4946 0.0077 98.44    
0.4964 0.0020 99.60    
Cascade_Stainless Steel_Trial 5 0.4899 0.0222 95.47 94.30  
0.4892 0.0401 91.80    
0.4902 0.0382 92.21    
0.4858 0.0243 95.00    
0.4940 0.0264 94.66    
0.4888 0.0236 95.17    
0.4869 0.0205 95.79    
0.4925 0.0198 95.98    
0.4948 0.0363 92.66    

Visual Analysis:
The Cascade cleaner had the best spotting (no spots) results out of the three, with an overall average rating of 1.4 out of 5, with 5 being the worst. The next best spotting cleaner was the Seventh Generation cleaner, with an overall average spotting rating of 1.8 out of 5. The worst spotting cleaner was the AGAE with an average overall spotting rating of 2.5 out of 5.

The Cascade cleaner also had the best filming (no film) results out of the three cleaners, with an average overall rating of 1.5 out of 5. The second best filming removal cleaner was the Seventh Generation cleaner with an overall average rating of 1.7 out of 5. The worst filming cleaner was the AGAE with an overall average rating of 2.3 out of 5.

Company: AGAE Spotting
Trial          
  Rating 1 2 3 Trial Avg. Overall Avg.
  2 3 2 2.3 2.5
  2 2 1 1.7  
  3 2 2 2.3  
  1 2 2 1.7  
  2 2 2 2  
  3 2 2 2.3  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  2 2 2 2  
  1 2 2 1.7  
  1 3 3 2.3  
Trial 2          
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 3 2 2  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1 3 2 2  
  2 2 1.5 1.8  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  1 3.5 2 2.2  
  1 2 1 1.3  
  1 4.5 4 3.2  
Trial 3          
  5 4 5 4.7  
  3 2 2.5 2.5  
  2.5 2 3 2.5  
  2.5 2 3 2.5  
  4 4 5 4.3  
  4 4 4 4  
  2 2 2 2  
  2 3 1 2  
  1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5  
  4 4 4 4  
Trial 4          
  4 2 3 3  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  5 2 3 3.3  
  4 3 3 3.3  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  3 3 3 3  
Trial 5          
  4 2 5 3.7  
  2 2 3 2.3  
  3 2.5 5 3.5  
  2 2 4 2.7  
  4 4 5 4.3  
  3 3.5 5 3.8  
  2 2 4 2.7  
  2 4 5 3.7  
  2 2 4 2.7  
  5 4 5 4.7  

Seventh Generation Spotting

Trial 1          
  Rating 1 2 3 Trial Avg. Overall Avg.
  2 1.5 2 1.8 1.8
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 2   2.5 2.2
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  1.5 1.5 1 1.3  
  2 2   2 2
  1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5  
  2 2   2 2
Trial 2          
  2 2.5 2 2.2  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 3   2 2.3
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  1 3   1.5 1.8
  3 4   2.5 3.2
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  3 3.5 1.5 2.7  
  3 1.5 1.5 2  
  2 4   2.5 2.8
Trial 3          
  2 2.5 2 2.2  
  2 2   1 1.7
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 2   1.5 1.8
  2 2   2 2
  1 2   1.5 1.5
  2 3   2 2.3
  2 2   1.5 1.8
  3 2   3 2.7
Trial 4          
  1 3   2 2
  1 1   1.5 1.2
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  1 1.5 2 1.5  
  1 1   3.5 1.8
  1 1.5 3 1.8  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1.5 3 1.8  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 2   2.5 1.8
Trial 5          
  1 3   1 1.7
  1 2   1 1.3
  1 3   1.5 1.8
  1 2   1.5 1.5
  1 4   1.5 2.2
  1.5 3   2.5 2.3
  1 2   1 1.3
  1 4   1 2
  1 2   1 1.3
  1.5 3   2 2.2

Cascade Spotting

Trial 1          
  Rating 1 2 3 Trial Avg. Overall Avg.
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3 1.4
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 1 2 1.3  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
Trial 2          
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1.5 1 1 1.2  
  1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  3 3.5 1 2.5  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  3 1 1.5 1.8  
Trial 3          
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
Trial 4          
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
Trial 5          
  2 2 1.5 1.8  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  1 2 1.5 1.5  
  2 2 1.5 1.8  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  2 2 1 1.7  

Seventh Generation Filming

Trial 1          
  Rating 1 2 3 Trial Avg.  Overall Avg.
  1 1 1.5 1.2 1.7
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1 2 1.3  
  1 1.5 2 1.5  
  2 2 2 2  
  1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  2 2 1.5 1.8  
Trial 2          
  2 2 3 2.3  
  2 1.5 1 1.5  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 2 3 2.3  
  2 2 2.5 2.2  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 2 2 2  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  3 3 2 2.7  
Trial 3          
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1.5 2 2 1.8  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  1 1.5 3 1.8  
  2 2 2 2  
  2 1.5 2.5 2  
Trial 4          
  1 2 1.5 1.5  
  2 2 1.5 1.8  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  1 3 2 2  
  1 2.5 2.5 2  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 3 1 1.7  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  1 2 1.5 1.5  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
Trial 5          
  1 2 2 1.7  
  2 2 1 1.7  
  1.5 1.5 2 1.7  
  1 2 1.5 1.5  
  1 2 3 2  
  1 2 1 1.3  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 2 3 2  
  1 1.5 2 1.5  
  1 2 2 1.7  
Company: Cascade          
Trial 1 Rating 1 2 3 Trial Avg. Overall Avg.
  2 1 2 1.7 1.5
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1 2 1.3  
  1 1 1 1  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
Trial 2          
  3 1 2 2  
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1.5 1 1.5 1.3  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  1.5 1 1 1.2  
  1 1 2 1.3  
  2 1 2 1.7  
  2 1 2 1.7  
  3 1.5 1 1.8  
  3 1.5 1 1.8  
Trial 3          
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 1.5 1.5 1.7  
  2 1 2 1.7  
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  2 1 2 1.7  
  2 1 2 1.7  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1 1.5 1.2  
Trial 4          
  2 1 1.5 1.5  
  1 1.5 1.5 1.3  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1.5 2 1.5  
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  2 1 1 1.3  
  2 1.5 2 1.8  
  1 1 2 1.3  
  2 1 2 1.7  
Trial 5          
  2 2.5 2 2.2  
  1 1.5 1 1.2  
  1 1.5 2 1.5  
  1 2.5 1.5 1.7  
  1 2 2 1.7  
  1 2 1 1.3  
  2 2 1.5 1.8  
  1 2 2.5 1.8  
  1 1.5 2 1.5  
  1 2 2 1.7  

In terms of overall cleaner effectiveness over the three substrates, the Seventh Generation cleaner was the best cleaner, averaging 98.2% removal. The AGAE cleaner was the second best with a removal of 96.83% and Cascade cleaner the third best with a removal of 96.24%. Overall, in regards to spotting and filming neutralization the Cascade cleaner was most effective, the Seventh Generation cleaner second, and the AGAGE cleaner third.

No relation

Name Class Section
Document Evaluation #0 Evaluation 3
Document Evaluation #1 Evaluation 3
Document Evaluation #2 Evaluation 3
Powered by eZ Publish™ CMS Open Source Web Content Management. Copyright © 1999-2014 eZ Systems AS (except where otherwise noted). All rights reserved.