Trial #0

Trial #0

To evaluate Biomor Odour Eliminator FM013525, Good Sense Odor Eliminator, and Chem Ecology Good Riddance against milk malodor.

2022

30

2

125

131

Part

07/18/2022

1,441.00

No relation

Alexander Symko
Tatyanna Moreland Junior

Glass/Quartz

Odor

None

None

Smell

Nine clean 250 ml glass bottles were filled with 6 ml of spoiled whole milk. The three supplied cleaning products required dilutions. Biomor Odour Eliminator FM013525 received a 1:20 dilution, Good Sense Odor Eliminator received a 1:10 dilution, and Chem Ecology Good Riddance cleaner received a 1:32 dilution. Three bottles were treated for each supplied cleaner for three treatment cycles, with each treatment cycle consisting of two sprays of the respective cleaner directly into the bottle. Following each treatment cycle the bottles were swirled around so the cleaner can mix with the cleaner. After each treatment cycle the panelists rated the malodor of the milk in the bottles.

The panelists rated the malodor of the milk after each treatment cycle, from a value of 1 defined as no malodor to a value of 5 as high malodor. Subsequently, the nine milk bottles were allowed to ferment at room temperature overnight to see if there are any increase in malodor level after an overnight sit. Thereafter, the same panelists rated the malodor of the milk after the overnight aging of the milk bottles. The nine bottles were then subjected to a final treatment cycle, which consisted of two sprays of their respective supplied cleaners. The panelists then rated the malodor level for each milk bottles.

Table 1: Biomor Odour Eliminator FM013525 Results

Table 2: Good Sense Odor Eliminator Results

Table 3: Chem Ecology Good Riddance

Table 4: Summary of Results from Untreated to Six Sprays

Table 5: Summary of Results Before And After Overnight Treatment

All three cleaners were effective at reducing malodor from spoiled milk. The supplied Good Sense Odor Eliminator product was found to be the most effective as it had the most favorable results after three treatment cycles with an average rating of 1.4 and overnight with two additional sprays with an average rating of 1. The Good Sense Odor Eliminator also was the only cleaner to keep the same malodor rating after sitting overnight. Biomor Odour Eliminator FM013525 and Chem Ecology Good Riddance ratings after overnight treatment both increased by 0.6-0.7. Biomor Odour Eliminator FM013525 was the second most effective with an average rating of 1.8 after three treatment cycles and a final average rating of 1.2 after two additional sprays following overnight treatment. Chem Ecology Good Riddance was the least effective among the cleaners with a three cycle treatment average of 2.7 and  a final average rating of 2.1.

Good Sense Odor Eliminator was the most effective at reducing malodor from spoiled milk, maintaining this reduction overnight, and further reducing malodor after an additional treatment cycle. Biomor Odour Eliminator FM013525 was the second most effective with a reduced average malodor rating after three cycles of treatment and a reduced malodor rating after an overnight period with an additional two sprays. Chem Ecology Good Riddance was the least effective among the cleaners with the highest malodor average rating after three cycles and the highest average rating after sitting overnight with an additional treatment cycle.

No relation