Default object view. Click to create a custom template, Node ID: 22944, Object ID: 23092

Trial #0

Trial #0

To compare the effectiveness of removing Hucker’s soil from a variety of surfaces using the supplied cleaning products.

2017

25

5

0

0

Coupon

12/19/2017

0.50

Manual Wipe

Hucker's Soil

None

Air dry

Gravimetric

Eighteen preweighed coupons, three for each substrate, were soiled with 0.5g of Hucker’s soil (44.2% Distilled water, 13.5% evaporated milk, 8.8% creamy peanut butter, 8.8% salted butter, 8.8% stone ground wheat flour, 8.8% egg yolks, 0.9% printer’s ink with boiled linseed oil, 2.7% saline solution, 3.5% India ink) using a swab. Coupons air dried at room temperature (68 F) for two hours before recording dirty weights. A sponge, provided by EcoEgg, was used to manually clean with both the supplied and comparative product. The sponge was saturated once with deionized water before rubbing it into the EcoEgg hard surface cleaner in a circular motion for five seconds. The coupons were cleaned one at a time for 30 seconds in a circular motion with a reapplication of the cleaner between each coupon. A dime sized drop of the comparative product was applied directly to the coupons one at a time and cleaned with a wet sponge for 30 sections in a circular motion. The coupons were dried by wiping once with a microfiber towel before taking clean weights and final observations.

Cleaner Substrate Initial wt Final wt % Removed Average % Removal Overall % Removal
Eco Egg Ceramic 0.4451 0.0052 98.83 95.22 94.70
0.4455 0.0367 91.76
0.5484 0.0270 95.08
Plastic 0.5266 0.0682 87.05 95.64
0.4149 0.0001 99.98
0.3504 0.0004 99.89
Painted Metal 0.2850 0.0182 93.61 93.24
0.3615 0.0228 93.69
0.3522 0.0267 92.42
Soft Scrub Ceramic 0.4475 0.0065 98.55 96.32 98.00
0.6066 0.0391 93.55
0.5825 0.0183 96.86
Plastic 0.7252 0.0133 98.17 99.09
0.6827 0.0024 99.65
0.6842 0.0038 99.44
Painted Metal 0.4059 0.0032 99.21 98.61
0.2784 0.0039 98.60
0.3207 0.0064 98.00

Observations:

EcoEgg’s product left behind some residue after cleaning the coupons, but it looks like it could be easily removed if a wet sponge was applied to the surface. Both products easily removed the soil.

EcoEgg’s Hard Surface Cleaner Citrus Burst is as effective as the comparative product at removing Hucker’s Soil from ceramic, plastic, and painted metal substrates.

No relation

Name Class Section
Document Evaluation #0 Evaluation 3
Document Evaluation #1 Evaluation 3
Powered by eZ Publish™ CMS Open Source Web Content Management. Copyright © 1999-2014 eZ Systems AS (except where otherwise noted). All rights reserved.