Default object view. Click to create a custom template, Node ID: 7583, Object ID: 7582

Trial #0

Trial #0

To evaluate the efficiency of a product for cleaning window surfaces

2015

23

2

0

0

Part

08/31/2015

5.00

Manual Wipe

There are no related objects.

Glass/Quartz

Dirt

None

Air dry

Timing
Visual

One 30”X40” section of window was marked off as a testing surface. To the surface, 5 grams of AATC was mixed in 400 ml water to create a soil solution. The mixture was applied by taking a paint roller and soaking it in the soil solution and then swiping the paint roller on the window surface 25 times. The soiled surface was allowed to dry for 20 minutes. Once the soil was dry, testing took place for all the cleaning tools in way that they would be used in real world conditions. For the first round of testing the participants were told to clean the window fully till no trace of soil could be found, they were not instructed on how to use the tools and were timed during their performance. When they were done with one window that window was cleaned and soiled for the next test in that round. For the second round of testing we performed similar analysis, but the test was run with the participants following manufacturer instructions for the paper towels and the microfiber pad. The microfiber towel was not run again. All evaluations are based on a time performance.

Tools Evaluated: Microfiber towel, Paper Towel- Bounty Dura Towel, Unger Microfiber Pad

Time Analysis Round 1 No Instructions: All Times are provided in seconds

  Microfiber towel Paper Towel Microfiber Pad
Lab Tech 1 32 33 23 29 32 30 19 25 18
Lab Tech 2 61 34 40 55 60 38 36 35 34
Lab Tech 3 34 34 23 66 47 27 22 29 27

Result of Time Analysis Round 2 with instructions: All Times are provided in seconds

  Paper Towels Microfiber Pad
Lab Tech 1 19 23 19 23 22 21
Lab Tech 2 37 34 27 21 25 24
Lab Tech 3 27 28 24 19 25 22

Summary

Round 1 Averages    
  Microfiber Paper Microfiber Pad
Lab Tech 1 29 30 21
Lab Tech 2 45 51 35
Lab Tech 3 30 47 26
Overall Average 35 43 27

Round 2

Round 2 Averages  
  Paper Towels  Microfiber Pad
Lab Tech 1 20 22
Lab Tech 2 33 23
Lab Tech 3 26 22
Overall Average 26 22

In both rounds of testing the Microfiber Pad (Unger Tool) performed better in cleaning the window than the other two cleaners, the microfiber pad also performed better with manufacturer instructions.

No relation

Name Class Section
Document Evaluation #0 Evaluation 3
Document Evaluation #1 Evaluation 3
Document Evaluation #2 Evaluation 3
Document Evaluation #3 Evaluation 3
Powered by eZ Publish™ CMS Open Source Web Content Management. Copyright © 1999-2014 eZ Systems AS (except where otherwise noted). All rights reserved.